HOME

CATHOLIC NEWS FROM THE PHOENIX DIOCESE

NAVIGATION

LOCAL NEWS

BRIEFS

NATION/WORLD

EDITORIAL

BISHOP'S COLUMN

LETTERS AND FEEDBACK

OPINION AND COMMENTARY

MEDIA/ARTS

CLASSIFIEDS

SUNBEAMS EVENT CALENDAR

PHOTOS

VIDEOS

MORE NEWS

BLOGTCS.COM

CATHOLIC NEWS SERVICE

CNS BLOG

SUPPLEMENTS

Welcome to the Diocese, a guide to the local Church [PDF]

The Phoenix Diocese's 2006-2007 Annual Report [PDF]

You Welcomed Me, a pastoral letter on migration [PDF]

Why is Marriage Important to the Catholic Church? [PDF]

Policy and Procedures for the Protection of Minors [PDF]

PHOENIX DIOCESE

BISHOP'S PAGE

DIOCESAN INFO

EDUCATION AND INFORMATION

PARISHES

OUTREACH AND SOCIAL MINISTRIES

CHANCERY

DEPARTMENTS

SCHOOLS

VOCATIONS

FIND A PRIEST

YOUTH PROTECTION

SAFE ENVIRONMENT

CATHOLIC CEMETERIES

EMPLOYMENT

DIOCESAN CALENDAR

CATHOLIC COMMUNITY

ARIZONA CATHOLIC CONFERENCE

CATHOLIC CHARITIES COMMUNITY SERVICES

CATHOLIC COMMUNITY FOUNDATION

CATHOLIC TUITION ORGANIZATION OF THE DIOCESE OF PHOENIX

FOUNDATION FOR SENIOR LIVING

LIFE TEEN

MERCY GILBERT MEDICAL CENTER

ST. JOSEPH'S HOSPITAL AND MEDICAL CENTER

SOCIETY OF ST. VINCENT DE PAUL

U.S. CHURCH

USCCB

READINGS AND PSALMS

MOVIES AND TV

BIBLE

BISHOPS' STATEMENTS

CATECHISM

YOUTH PROTECTION

USCCB PUBLICATIONS

FOR YOUR MARRIAGE

INSIDE THE CURIA

POPE BENEDICT XVI

BIOGRAPHY

POPE JOHN PAUL II

BIOGRAPHY

WORLD TRAVELS

U.S. TRAVELS

BEATIFICATIONS

CANONIZATIONS

WRITINGS

JOHN PAUL TO BENEDICT

MEDIA/ARTS

Film Review

'Changeling': Eastwood’s latest not his greatest

A Christian minister brings to light the great injustices of the 1928 Los Angeles Police Department in Clint Eastwood’s latest film.

Rev. Gustav Briegleb, played by John Malkovich, is a Presbyterian minister dedicated to exposing the LAPD corruption in “Changeling.” That’s why Christine Collins, played by Angelina Jolie, comes to him.

Collins’ son goes missing. The police claim to have found the missing child, but when they bring him to Collins, she realizes it’s not her son.

When Collins protests, the authorities force her into a psychiatric ward. There she meets other women who have similarly upset the LAPD.

Rev. Briegleb gets Collins released from the psychiatric ward and then takes up her cause against the LAPD. Meanwhile, she continues searching for her son, even after everyone has advised her to give up hope.

“Changeling” — a word fancifully denoting a child who is believed to be switched by fairies as an infant, unbeknownst to the parents — is based on a true story. Unfortunately, the history details are a bit too much for just one film. The result is a movie that goes on too long, touches on many ideas, and does not drive home any one concept with great force.

The corruption of the police department is up against the angst of a mother who has lost her child, her relationship to a serial killer and a reverend seeking justice. There are too many threads and they are not woven together effectively.

That said, Jolie as Collins is terrific, if a bit overly aware of the near hysteria she should be portraying. Eastwood focuses too much on Jolie’s beauty, as a close up of her occupies the screen for what feels like the majority of the film.

The best performance comes from Malkovich as Rev. Gustav Briegleb. A tremendous character to play, Malkovich is the most convincing.

Although he probably overuses his pulpit, the minister certainly extols the Gospel virtue of justice against a system rife with corruption.

The Catechism of the Catholic Church directs laity to “remedy the institutions and conditions of the world when the latter are an inducement to sin, that these may be conformed to the norms of justice, favoring rather than hindering the practice of virtue” (909).

The minister’s message and actions echo the Catechism’s directive. His storyline forces audience members to consider their own call to justice.

The film is often predictable — as films based on true stories often are — and it is overly indulgent in the length. With strong acting and atmosphere, “Changeling” has all the components of a great film. It simply does not come together with enough cohesion to deserve much praise.

CNS photo/Universal

Angelina Jolie and Gattlin Griffith star in the new film "Changeling."

Changeling
(Universal)

Gripping true-life drama set in 1928 Los Angeles recounting how the young son of a single telephone operator goes missing, and how the corrupt LAPD tries to silence her when she protests that the child they subsequently return to her is not her son.

The USCCB classification is A-III — adults. The Motion Picture Association of America rating is R — restricted. Under 17 requires accompanying parent or adult guardian.

Catholic Sun rating

Message: Strong

Artistic merit: Strong

MEDIA/ARTS

'Sun' columnist took long road to success

BOOK: Tough questions find answer in God

FILM: Saving power of Christ murky in lukewarm 'Poole'

FILM: 'Swing Vote' stresses political participation

BOOK: Author takes another look at St. Joan of Arc

BOOK: 'Sun' writer finds meaning in loss

RECENT STORIES

Catholic schools begin year with excitement, changes

Upcoming celebration to grow scholarship funds for Catholic schools

New Catholic school opens; two others embrace changes

Students encouraged to apply for Christian Service Awards scholarships

Five priests begin chaplaincy at diocesan high schools

A new frontier: Religious orders plan joint effort on the border

Holy Year, holy journey: Local Catholics prepare for Pauline pilgrimage

Foundation for Senior Living debuts newest adult health center

Newborn baby found at doorstep to St. Mark’s

Sudanese 'Lost Boy' visits Seton community

'Fire' to reignite faith

Your Catholic Neighbor: JoAnn Goodall

LOCAL PHOTOS

PHOTO ARCHIVE

PURCHASE A PHOTO

MAP OF PHOTOS

TOOLBOX

SEND US A STORY IDEA

CONTACT US

PURCHASE A PHOTO

FIND A PARISH

DAILY PRAYER

SAINT OF THE DAY


Copyright 2006-2008 The Catholic Sun Newspaper. All Rights Reserved. Contact The Catholic Sun.