More security isn’t answer to prevent shootings, say Catholic educators

Krista Rekos, the mother of Sandy Hook Elementary school student Jessica Rekos, embraces a young man following Jessica's funeral Mass at St. Rose of Lima Church in Newtown, Conn., Dec. 18. Mourners packed back-to-back services at the church that day for Jessica and James Mattioli, two of the 20 young victims of the Newtown shooting massacre. (CNS photo/Shannon Stapleton, Reuters)
Krista Rekos, the mother of Sandy Hook Elementary school student Jessica Rekos, embraces a young man following Jessica’s funeral Mass at St. Rose of Lima Church in Newtown, Conn., Dec. 18. Mourners packed back-to-back services at the church that day for Jessica and James Mattioli, two of the 20 young victims of the Newtown shooting massacre. (CNS photo/Shannon Stapleton, Reuters)

WASHINGTON (CNS) — In the wake of the Dec. 14 shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Conn., Catholic education officials have primarily focused on providing administrators with the resources they need for teachers and parents to help students cope with the horrific tragedy.

The U.S. bishops’ education secretariat, the National Catholic Educational Association and the Council for American Private Education, quickly posted guidelines on their websites about how to talk to children about violence.

These guidelines emphasized the need to assure children of their safety, keep explanations appropriate for children’s ages and limit exposure to television coverage of the event.

Karen Ristau, president of the National Catholic Educational Association, said the next step is to provide resources for schools to tap into available programs that help students find peaceful solutions and help teachers identify students who are isolated and without peers.

Ristau told Catholic News Service that information would be more useful than “having more locks on the doors.”

Dominican Sister John Mary Fleming, head of the U.S. bishops’ Secretariat of Catholic Education, said the guidelines’ advice that parents should assure their children they are safe in school has raised questions among those who said this was no longer true.

In response, Sister John Mary, a member of the Dominican Sisters of St. Cecilia Congregation in Nashville, Tenn., said that children should be assured that the adults in their lives “are doing everything possible to keep them safe.”

She also noted that nearly all schools, particularly after the 1999 shooting at Colorado’s Columbine High School, have strict safety measures in place, as did Sandy Hook School, the scene of the recent shootings that left 20 children and seven adults dead.

She told CNS that most schools, Catholic schools included, not only have strict policies about admitting people into their buildings but also have crisis management policies, safety drills and lockdown procedures.

Since the school in Newtown also followed these procedures, she said the shooting demonstrates that “society as a whole needs to address this in different way” specifically looking at the issue of gun control.

Patricia McGuire, president of Trinity Washington University, likewise noted in a Dec. 17 blog on Huffington Post, that since the Columbine shooting, schools have “beefed-up security, instituted lockdown drills, and trained teachers on how to protect their pupils from the unthinkable.”

McGuire urged fellow educators to honor the courage and sacrifice of Sandy Hook’s teachers and principal by “insisting that this nation enact laws to protect our students and campus communities from the harm of violent minds with easily accessible weapons in hand.”

In helping students immediately cope with this tragedy, Sister John Mary urged Catholic school superintendents to not only provide resources to parents and teachers but to also use the tragedy as an opportunity for prayer and as a teaching moment.

“Our schools afford us the perfect opportunity to speak about redemption, grace and heaven,” she wrote in a Dec. 17 letter to Catholic school superintendents.

She also noted that children and parents are “seeking to understand and make sense of this very difficult event. The question being asked is how God can allow this to happen?” Catholic educators, she said, can address this difficult issue by stressing the free will people have been given to make choices for good or evil.

“Learning to support each other to make good choices is a way to talk about how we can support each other in dealing with the tragedy,” she said. She also advised educators to highlight the heroic acts of the principal, teachers and individual students in Newtown.

“They are pulling virtue from their toes,” Sister John Mary told CNS, referring to how the townspeople of Newtown have joined together as a community in their care and support for one another.

Both Sister John Mary and Ristau noted that several Catholic schools across the country have held prayer services for the victims of the Sandy Hook shooting.

Classes at St. Rose of Lima School in Newtown were canceled the week after the shootings to protect students from the sight of twice daily funerals at the church, according to the director of communications for the Diocese of Bridgeport, Conn.

— By Carol Zimmermann Catholic News Service 


  1. Once again some Catholic educators are just getting it wrong. Training teachers to huddle in the corner of the classroom with their 20 or so defenseless charges is NOT how to handle this kind of situation. Defenseless, passive teachers working with defenseless, passive administrators to educate defenseless children into total passiveness is just insanity. The only way to prevent or stop an attack such as this is to have a corps of trained and armed teachers (yes, I said teachers) and administrators who are ready to respond in seconds to a hint of danger. Make your school into one that a criminal will pass by, because he is afraid to enter. Prevention includes teaching children they should NOT just wait to be killed. Catholics are allowed to defend themselves against evil.

    Then, have educators start letting little boys be boys, playing competitive games and being responsibly aggressive without the constant redress of disapproval or threats of Ridalin. Teach the little girls they can protect and defend themselves, and how to do it. Teach them about their rights and their freedoms, and how to protect them.

    And how about a little condemnation of the secular threats in the media that seek to steal the souls of our youth and their parents. Educate the families, and protect the students.

  2. TSN John:
    An armed corps of teachers? What will we be teaching children if they have to pass armed guards going into classes each day? That seeing someone checking them in and out with semi-automatic weapons is a normal way to live? Is this Communist Russia? Is that what we, as Americans, have fallen to?

    The principle chased into the gunman. She wasn’t cowering, and she was killed. I suppose that Jesus said, turn the other cheek and then use your autoloader to blast your enemies to hell. Yes, so very Christ-like on your part.

    But the reason I came to this page was that I was looking for the American Catholic hierarchy’s response to the shootings. There has been none. The bishops and cardinals have been silent on the issue. As a pro-life Catholic, I am amazed. As much time that was expended on contraceptives during the election campaign, saying that they killed future children, where is the bishopric outrage on this issue? Is the Catholic Church in America in bed with the NRA on this abomination of Jesus’ message?

    Just once, just one bishop, please come out and say that this insanity has to stop. How many babies are aborted a year? Aren’t those children that are walking the earth just as important as those unborn children are? In 2011, 8,583 Americans were gunned down. That is more than all of the dead in Iraq and Afghanistan wars. It is three times more than the World Trade Center. Where is the call to stop it from our leaders?

    I am ashamed that they have no courage to act or respond. Thank you. You make me ashamed to be a Catholic. What would Jesus do? I doubt that he would have stood there, taking money from a group that says we have to fear their members, the NRA. I doubtr that he would be telling people that they should be in a position to kill anyone they think is a threat, as is Mr TSN JOHN advocating.

    Please, bishops, say this is wrong. It is murder. It is only murder, not the word of Jesus. Please preach the word of Jesus on this.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.