Life of African-American priest told through play ‘From Slave to Priest’

By Joyce Duriga
Catholic News Service

Servant of God Father Augustus Tolton

Born: April 1, 1854
Ordained: April 24, 1886 at St. John Lateran Basilica for the Diocese of Alton (now Springfield)
Assigned to the Archdiocese of Chicago: Dec. 19, 1889
Died: July 9, 1897
Declared Servant of God: Feb. 13, 2012

CLICK HERE to learn more about Fr. Tolton’s life and cause for canonization.

CLICK HERE to learn more about “Tolton: From Slave to Priest,” a one-man play on Fr. Tolton’s life.

CHICAGO (CNS) — The life of Fr. Augustus Tolton already reads like a novel and now it is immortalized on stage with the new play “Tolton: From Slave to Priest,” produced by St. Luke Productions from Battle Ground, Washington.

Tolton, a former slave, is the first recognized American diocesan priest of African descent (Bishop James A. Healy of Portland, Maine, was ordained a priest in 1854 and his brother Jesuit Father Patrick Healey in 1864 — they claimed Irish ancestry, but were one-quarter black). The Archdiocese of Chicago opened his cause for sainthood in 2011, giving him the title “Servant of God.”

Born into slavery, he fled with his mother and siblings through the woods of northern Missouri and across the Mississippi River while being pursued by soldiers when he was only 9 years old. The small family made their home in Quincy, Illinois, a sanctuary for runaway slaves.

The boy’s father had died earlier in St. Louis, after escaping slavery to serve in the Union Army.

Growing up in Quincy and serving at Mass, young Augustus felt a call to the priesthood, but, because of rampant racism, no seminary in the United States would accept him. He headed to Rome, convinced he would become a missionary priest serving in Africa. However, after ordination, he was sent back to his hometown to be a missionary to the community there, again facing rampant racism.

He was such a good preacher that many white Catholics joined his black parishioners in the pews for his Masses. This upset white priests in the town, so Fr. Tolton headed north to Chicago, at the request of Archbishop Patrick Feehan, to minister to the black Catholic community there.

Fr. Tolton worked to the point of exhaustion for his congregation in Chicago, and on July 9, 1897, he died of heatstroke while returning from a priests’ retreat. He was 43.

His journey is now crystallized in a 90-minute, one-person play that premiered Nov. 5 at Chicago’s DuSable Museum of African American History. For over 30 years, St. Luke Productions has produced other plays about holy men and women, including St. Faustina, St. Maximilian Kolbe and St. John Vianney.

Andrae Goodnight portrays Father Augustus Tolton in the production “Tolton: From Slave to Priest” at DuSable Museum of African American History in Chicago Nov. 5. (CNS photo/Karen Callaway, Chicago Catholic)

Leonardo Defilippis, president and founder of St. Luke Productions, first learned of Fr. Tolton from a priest in the Diocese of Springfield, which includes the town of Quincy where the priest served and is buried.

Defilippis researched Fr. Tolton’s life and hung a photo of him in his office. When deciding which play he would produce next, he noticed the photo again and started praying to Fr. Tolton. Defilippis said he felt the Holy Spirit was asking him to make a play of the priest’s life.

Once decided, the producer reached out to Cardinal Francis E. George, who as Chicago’s archbishop at the time had opened Fr. Tolton’s cause for canonization during the Year of the Priest. The cardinal directed him to Chicago Auxiliary Bishop Joseph N. Perry, postulator of Fr. Tolton’s cause. Defilippis said he and his team worked closely with Bishop Perry on the play.

“It’s exciting to do something in complete conjunction with the canonization process. It’s a tool that can be used for this,” he told the Chicago Catholic, the archdiocesan newspaper. “It’s one of the most unique shows right now in theater because it’s a multimedia show, which means you have characters on a screen that are interacting with a live actor.”

Defilippis has created a “very unique art form” that makes it easy for groups anywhere to host the play because of the simple setup.

Andrae Goodnight portrays Father Augustus Tolton in the production “Tolton: From Slave to Priest” at DuSable Museum of African American History in Chicago Nov. 5. (CNS photo/Karen Callaway, Chicago Catholic)

When writing the script, Defilippis, who co-wrote the play with his wife, pulled from themes in Fr. Tolton’s life — perseverance, trust in God, incredible forgiveness and his priesthood.

Defilippis believes the time Fr. Tolton spent studying for the priesthood in Rome opened him up to the universality of a priest’s ministry. He studied with men from all over the world and saw the Church’s history in places like the catacombs, the Coliseum and St. Peter’s Basilica.

“Once he becomes a priest, he’s a priest for all. This is not a segregated situation, it’s not a segregated mindset,” Defilippis said.

The play doesn’t shy away from the harsh realities Fr. Tolton faced, such as severe prejudice against him from fellow priests in Quincy. The post-Reconstruction period was a troubled time for the United States, and tensions and violence were real. Fr. Tolton himself often spoke of being watched.

Defilippis believes that telling Fr. Tolton’s story through art is a way to bring light into today’s seemingly dark world.

“The highest form of art is when you not only entertain and inspire, but bring it to another level, of what we call evangelization of what actually touches hearts in a deep and impactful way that actually changes lives,” he said. “That’s what we’ve seen with these plays.”


Duriga is editor of the CHICAGO CATHOLIC, newspaper of the Archdiocese of Chicago.